Pop Culture Victim
Thursday, February 10, 2005
  Puts things into perspective, no?
BoingBoing has a rather disturbing post about the differences between stealing a DVD in a store and downloading it. While I find it ludicrous that the penalties are so much higher for infringement, it's not really surprising in the slightest. I would like to know if that's the case in more countries though, or if it's just the Yankees that have lost their marbles.

Or have they? One could make the argument that downloading should be much more severe than shoplifting, since it's so easy. Anyone with an internet connection can hop on to Gnutella and grab the latest Britney Spears mp3, but it takes at least some skill and a bit of luck to walk into a Wal-mart, nick the CD and escape. The difference is, of course, that downloading music is not technically stealing. Compare it to walking into the same Wal-mart, wiggling your nose and having a brand new copy of the CD appear in your hand. Neither you nor Wal-mart has paid for this disc, and they don't lose any stock. If you originally had the intent to purchase the CD, Wal-mart lost a sale, but if you worked your voodoo just for the hell of it, they didn't and are none the worse off, aside from not being able to convince you to give them money in exchange for goods.

I think the whole infringement issue could be dealt with far more effectively if the entertainment industry were able to view infringement not as theft, but as them failing to be able to get people to buy their music. This is not a criminal issue - it's an economic one.
 
Comments: Post a Comment

<< Home
What I think.

My Photo
Name:
Location: The Great White North, Canada
RECENT POSTS
I've got Mono, and I love it.
"Couple of cool guys...
Superman is a dick.
Why all the children love both Mozilla and Gamera
Ever noticed how the most random things spark rants?
This weekend is officially I Love Comic Books weekend
Dear America,
This week, in screwed-up dreams
My new career
I drawed a picture. It took a lot of squeezing of ...

GOOD BLOGS
BoingBoing
Warren Ellis
Mimi Smartypants
Websnark
Wonderland
One Good Thing
Neil Gaiman
Latigo Flint
Drug WarRant
Kung-Fu Monkey
Pre-Shrunk
Defective Yeti
Lawrence Lessig
Evil Avatar
Digital Copyright Canada
Techdirt

GOOD PODCASTS
Daily Sonic
Geek Fu Action Grip
Wingin' It with Mike and Evo

GOOD COMICS
8-bit Theatre
Alien Loves Predator
Angel Moxie
Checkerboard Nightmare
Chopping Block
Comet 7
Dork Tower
El Goonish Shive
Elf Only Inn
Girls With Slingshots
goats: the comic strip
Instant Classic
The Perry Bible Fellowship
Jeremy
Least I Could Do
Mac Hall Comics
MegaTokyo
Men In Hats
Narbonic!
Nodwick
Penny Arcade!
Piled Higher and Deeper
PvP
Queen of Wands :'(
Questionable Content
Real Life
Red Meat
Road Waffles
RPG World
Sam and Fuzzy
Scary Go Round
Sinfest
Skirting Danger
Sluggy Freelance
Something Positive
Sore Thumbs
Spells & Whistles
Strong Bad's E-mail
The Doctor Pepper Show
The New Adventures of Bobbin!
Wigu
Jeff Rowland's Overcompensating!
Tony Esteves's Cigarro & Cerveja
Two Lumps
Underpower
VG Cats
White Ninja Comics
Wulffmorgenthaler

ARCHIVES
January 2004
February 2004
March 2004
April 2004
May 2004
June 2004
July 2004
August 2004
September 2004
October 2004
November 2004
December 2004
January 2005
February 2005
March 2005
April 2005
May 2005
June 2005
July 2005
August 2005

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Powered by Blogger